North Academy
Would you like to react to this message? Create an account in a few clicks or log in to continue.


A Duel Academy for everyone!
 
HomePortalSearchLatest imagesRegisterLog in
The academy has been shut down, please click here for more details.

North Academy :: Discussions :: Extra Discussion
 

 this is my first time i not sure my ruling is correct or not......

Go down 
5 posters
AuthorMessage
patrick1324
Ra Yellow
Ra Yellow



Immune to warnings? : No
Warnings : No Warning
Posts : 794
Reputation : 6
Join date : 2014-02-25

this is my first time i not sure my ruling is correct or not...... Empty
PostSubject: this is my first time i not sure my ruling is correct or not......   this is my first time i not sure my ruling is correct or not...... EmptyWed Jul 09, 2014 6:56 am
i just watch a duel and there meet this situation

1) player A summon a galaxy-eyes photon dragon with starliegevlord galaxion effect.

2) player A's galaxy-eyes photon dragon atk a monster and activate galaxy-eyes photon dragon to banish and return to field.

3) player B summon silent honor ark and activate effect........

now the problem come, player A say galaxy-eyes photon dragon already banish and return to field, it is not longer a special summoned monster and silent honor cannot target it with effect==

ok, i have 2 set ruling skill is fighting in my brain

normally when a monster flip face down, remove from field......
those special effect that aplied in that monster will all reset.

but i dont know this thing is down to this categories or not.........

this is my first time i not sure about my ruling...........

hope an admin can explain it, and dont just say can target or cannot target.............

from,
patrick1324
Back to top Go down
Guest
Guest




this is my first time i not sure my ruling is correct or not...... Empty
PostSubject: Re: this is my first time i not sure my ruling is correct or not......   this is my first time i not sure my ruling is correct or not...... EmptyWed Jul 09, 2014 7:06 am
Thing to understand is before the effect of galaxy eyes photon dragon was even activated... it was special summoned... the effect meerly removes it from the field temporarly..... so silent honor ark effect will still work on galaxy eyes.
Back to top Go down
patrick1324
Ra Yellow
Ra Yellow



Immune to warnings? : No
Warnings : No Warning
Posts : 794
Reputation : 6
Join date : 2014-02-25

this is my first time i not sure my ruling is correct or not...... Empty
PostSubject: Re: this is my first time i not sure my ruling is correct or not......   this is my first time i not sure my ruling is correct or not...... EmptyWed Jul 09, 2014 7:09 am
that player A say like he is right, so i also not very sure because i never meet this situation==
Back to top Go down
Lucy
Obelisk Blue
Obelisk Blue



Immune to warnings? : No
Warnings : No Warning
Posts : 50
Reputation : 0
Join date : 2014-07-05

this is my first time i not sure my ruling is correct or not...... Empty
PostSubject: Re: this is my first time i not sure my ruling is correct or not......   this is my first time i not sure my ruling is correct or not...... EmptyWed Jul 09, 2014 7:15 am
It's okay, i would off gotten confused too =(
Besides, it's not like you get into these scenarios everyday.
Back to top Go down
AF7
Fire Fists Player
Fire Fists Player
AF7


Immune to warnings? : No
Warnings : 3rd Warning
Posts : 243
Reputation : 0
Join date : 2014-01-23
Location : k.

this is my first time i not sure my ruling is correct or not...... Empty
PostSubject: Re: this is my first time i not sure my ruling is correct or not......   this is my first time i not sure my ruling is correct or not...... EmptyWed Jul 09, 2014 7:49 am
it is "returned". it is still considered as being special summoned
Back to top Go down
Hero
Assistant
Assistant
Hero


Immune to warnings? : No
Warnings : First Warning
Losses : 1
Wins : 3
Posts : 2958
Reputation : 3
Join date : 2014-02-06

this is my first time i not sure my ruling is correct or not...... Empty
PostSubject: Re: this is my first time i not sure my ruling is correct or not......   this is my first time i not sure my ruling is correct or not...... EmptyWed Jul 09, 2014 10:23 am
If it's returned,then it's still considered as a SS.
Back to top Go down
Professor Banner
Obelisk Blue
Obelisk Blue
Professor Banner


Immune to warnings? : No
Warnings : 3rd Warning
Posts : 2410
Reputation : 2
Join date : 2014-01-03
Age : 26

this is my first time i not sure my ruling is correct or not...... Empty
PostSubject: Re: this is my first time i not sure my ruling is correct or not......   this is my first time i not sure my ruling is correct or not...... EmptyWed Jul 09, 2014 11:13 am
lol jaden u copied what af7 said Razz
Back to top Go down
Sponsored content





this is my first time i not sure my ruling is correct or not...... Empty
PostSubject: Re: this is my first time i not sure my ruling is correct or not......   this is my first time i not sure my ruling is correct or not...... Empty
Back to top Go down
 
this is my first time i not sure my ruling is correct or not......
Back to top 
Page 1 of 1
 Similar topics
-
» hidden ruling 2 (destroy immediately)
» evol ruling problem
» BB Glassjaw ruling issues
» Chain Link ruling lesson
» "Miss-Timing" Ruling Lesson.

Permissions in this forum:You cannot reply to topics in this forum
North Academy :: Discussions :: Extra Discussion-
Jump to: