The Dorm Testing Rubric

Tester's Deck:
Testee's Deck:

What deck the tester used and what deck the testee used.

Ruling -10/10
The score they received on the academy's ruling exam.

Deck Build - 10/10
Is the deck competitive, does it flow together? Also make sure to post comments and suggestions if you have any.

5 for competitveness 5 for synergy

Skill - 45/45
Siding Skills, Play style and the control of the duel. State how well they sided if they did, what is their play style and how they have utilized it and explain how much control they had.

20 for control of duel,10 for siding and side deck, 15 for focus


Result of Duel - 15/15(0/10 for winning no duels, 5/15 for losing 2-1, 10/15 for winning 2-1 and 15/15 for winning 2-0)

Total: 80/80
Don't be too harsh or too easy on them on each of the above methods of testing.


Slifer Red 0-59
Ra Yellow 60-70
Obelisk Blue 71-80

Banned decks: alternative win, burn, troll deck, deck destruction


Note: TO take the test, you need to use a devpro or ygopro software.

To download Devpro,

[Only admins are allowed to see this link]

To Download Ygopro

[Only admins are allowed to see this link]

My suggestion is that the rubic should remain the same except that you should remove the atittude part and make deck builds 30 and skill 30 as those are important aspects of yugioh more then skill... Furthermore one as far as rulings go we need a rulings test, as judging someone understand rulings on the field isnt enough evidence to assess their knowledge of rulings.... thats pretty much it really

I was thinking to cut 10 points from attitude and add them equally to build and skill,and for the duel results it should be,5 for one win 10 for 2 wins and 20 for 2 wins wthout lose

Sometimes the attitude does come into play though. If they are going to be unpleasent towards me for no reason thats not right..

Sometimes the attitude does come into play though. If they are going to be unpleasent towards me for no reason thats not right..

Jaguar has a point.... attitude still matters when you put it that way, how about this... we go with celeses idea ie equally make deck build and skill 30 attitude cut down to 5 as well as the win result adjustments.... but at the same time we go with my idea with the rulings test.... Agreed?

the attitude will be cut down to 10 and skill and build will be 25

ok agree with celes

can we edit the rubric so it is correct? if were making the changes lets do it!

rubic updated.

rubic updated ra yellow passing grade is now 70 to 89 slifer is 69 and below.

rubic updated
Changes: reduce win/loss factor to 5/5, unbanned qliphorts, expanded skill factor.

updated

update, rulings test taken off until the new rulings test is made

meta list has been added

apparently you can use meta now

rubric update skill to 40
build to 10
ruling test added

You should change the ruling test to the new link, since you're using that now.

did already i think,also i am updating the dorm scales this weekend but 85 and up is obbi

It's still flames's link up there. You need to change it unless you're actually going to use it instead.

Dorm rubric updated, meta is now banned.

wait what??? i don't get why u guys are making the testing boring.....fk it even tho u did it now just don't do it for abandoned, cuz we need to see the potential of the player with the current META and if we bann it on abandoned....ANYONE CAN BE ABANDONED WITH SHIT DECKS LIKE BLACKWINGS

King Striker wrote:

wait what??? i don't get why u guys are making the testing boring.....fk it even tho u did it now just don't do it for abandoned, cuz we need to see the potential of the player with the current META and if we bann it on abandoned....ANYONE CAN BE ABANDONED WITH SHIT DECKS LIKE BLACKWINGS

We're trying to make the test results more valid. If Meta is allowed then just deck choice alone will make what would be a valid result invalid. If the tester goes with Qli and the testee goes with Wind-Ups, then the person playing wind-ups is not going get good results, which is not down to the person and his deck building ability and ruling knowledge, it's down to the massive difference in deck choices. So if everyone is stopped from using Meta, then we can pump out more valid results. As for abandoned, if we use non-meta decks, then it won't matter that someone got in with blackwings because they still have to beat what ever the tester chooses to use, which could be something non-meta that is still a challenge for the person to beat.

bump

Dorm Rubric updated